Tofts Grand Scoop | Exquisite Hand-Dipped Ice Cream in Columbus

Overview

Toft's Grand Scoop, located on W 5th Avenue in Columbus, Ohio, is a gem for ice cream lovers seeking both classic indulgence and subtle innovations. This ice cream shop masters the art of rich, creamy textures paired with well-balanced flavors that cater to a broad audience—from families craving nostalgic treats to adventurous foodies eager to sample thoughtfully crafted varieties.

Their menu highlights some standout creations like the Cookie Monster Double Scoop, which offers a playful yet satisfying blend of cookie pieces and smooth ice cream. Equally impressive is the Black Cherry Cone, loaded with luscious cherry chunks that deliver a fresh burst of fruitiness without overwhelming sweetness. For those looking to take a bit of Toft's magic home, the Lake Erie Cookie Island Monster Quart is a generous offering—combining indulgent cookie bits with velvety ice cream for a memorable dessert experience.

What separates Toft's from other local options is their commitment to classics enhanced with rich, deep flavors like peanut butter, bourbon, and truffle. Customers consistently highlight the creamy mouthfeel and the satisfying heft of their portions, making it a great pick for anyone eager to indulge without feeling rushed or overwhelmed by crowds. The option to sample flavors before ordering adds a thoughtful touch, inviting patrons to explore without guesswork.

The shop’s interior invites a welcoming ambiance—warm, comfortable, and free from the usual rush found in busier ice cream parlors. Friendly staff enrich the experience, ready to guide visitors through their diverse selection and recommend must-try scoops, creating a personalized treat that feels both generous and special.

Ideal for local families, couples on casual dates, or those simply looking to satisfy a craving for well-crafted ice cream, Toft’s Grand Scoop earns its place as a go-to spot in Columbus. Whether you’re drawn by timeless favorites or eager to savor a nuanced twist on classic flavors, this shop delivers a dependable, delightful ice cream experience that invites repeat visits.

Menu Highlights

See Full Menu

Amenities & Services

Popular for

Solo dining

Atmosphere

Casual

What Customers Say

Derek Miller

Dec 11,2025

5/5

The only ice cream in Columbus on par with Jeni's, but for different reasons. While Jeni's emphasizes unique and fresh ingredients, Toft's really shines at mastering classic, rich flavors with subtle twists. If you love chocolate, peanut butter, salted, truffle, buckeye, cookie, caramel, or bourbon type flavors, you will love Toft's. They do these extremely well, with very creamy texture and strong flavors in large portions for the price. It's not usually busy and you can taste everything to decide. Go support them so I can get Brown Butter Bourbon Truffle every summer

Sheila Boneske

Dec 11,2025

5/5

We loved visiting this place in Upper Sandusky but had no idea there was one in Columbus. There were so many amazing and delicious flavors to choose from, and you can sample a flavor for free. They also have sundae's, banana splits, and many other favorites. Many choices of dishes and cones, and the prices are very reasonable while the portions are big. We got 2 scoops for $6. We're looking forward to going back soon.

Harley

Dec 11,2025

5/5

Looove this ice cream place! The prices are great for what you get and the ice cream itself is very good! Very good customer service as well!

Vincent Lam

Dec 11,2025

5/5

This lovely ice cream shop was impressive. The room was lovely and service was friendly. Their ice cream was innovative and delicious without too much sugar. Samples were available. I got the sweet black cherry one. There were decent cherry chunks in it. The price was reasonable.

Taylor Threlkeld

Dec 11,2025

5/5

So good! The ice cream doesn't taste milky, but is exceptionally creamy and smooth. We sampled most of the flavors on offer, and didn't taste anything we didn't like. The girl that helped us was super friendly and helpful. Truly excellent ice cream. And the sugar googly eyes are a cute, fun addition.

Bri Ridenour

Dec 11,2025

5/5

My friend and I visited on a Wednesday night and found there to be no wait! The staff was incredibly friendly, described the history of the ice cream, and was super patient with us as we tried a bunch of flavors! Not only can you get two different kinds of ice cream for a small, but the portion size was also pretty decent! The ice cream itself had a great texture and flavor. I also can’t forget about the cute little candy eyes on the ice cream either! Although the sitting area is small, we were able to stay for sometime and chat as the atmosphere is very cozy. I definitely recommend checking this place out as I know I will definitely be back!

Mireille Bitangacha

Dec 11,2025

5/5

My new favorite ice cream spot in Columbus. Every flavor I’ve tried is delicious. I recommend the blueberry waffle cone, cookie dough, & brownie batter flavor, but I’m sure you won’t be disappointed with whatever choice you choose :)

ZVN ATX

Dec 11,2025

5/5

Fantastic ice cream experience. I ordered a medium ice cream and chose rainbow sherbet, cherry something and cookies and cream and the quality and portion was great. It felt really natural. The customer service provided was awesome as well.